Quantcast
  1. Scribblings now has a Word Count Validator, as requested. Users can save their wordcount and embed it in their posts via the [wordtrack] BBcode, or just use [wordcount] to embed without saving.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. The sub forums have all been merged into Time for Tea. Hugs and Good News remain seperate and may be removed rather than merged due to confidentiality concerns.
    Dismiss Notice

A car crash of an interview

Discussion in 'Time for Tea' started by Tregaron, July 20, 2018.

  1. Tregaron

    Tregaron Member

    This is in the news, but I have to say I don't think I have seen such an unnecessarily rude interviewer in a very long time. Naga Munchetty cut off Sir David Attenborough repeatedly, stared at her notes throughout, and kept trying to avoid discussing what he had been invited there to discuss. What on earth do the BBC think they are doing?

     
  2. Reader

    Reader Vile Critic

    The section that began "We can't talk..." was simply painful. What I object to is that he was invited to discuss the butterfly count and instead she started asking about meeting the Queen, and plastics, which have nothing to do with the topic. It smacks of false pretenses.

    However at 92, he still has a sense of humour to be lauded, and I must congratulate him for slipping this past his oblivious interviewer.
    “And how did you feel when you saw it launch?”
    “It was a very moving occasion,”
     
  3. tirial

    tirial IT fixer extraordinaire

    She does seem to have forgotten how to ask feeder questions: Why is the butterfly count important? How do people take part? What might be causing the decline? What can we do to improve matters? Why are you supporting it?

    Listening to it, I honestly feel as though someone, either the presenter or her editor, went off-script to try and get a scoop. The person responsible should not be working on live television. Even if it was the editor, the presenter (complete with ums, errs, and pauses) still chose to go along with it, and takes responsibility.
     
  4. Mine all mine

    Mine all mine Member

    That was a bad interview. Those notes she's reading from should be readable in Hi-def. Can anyone get a copy?
     
  5. jessica

    jessica Active Member

    Lots of fuss about this on twitter. The worst bit's the bit where he tries to get back to the subject::unsure::, and she actually forces the interview back off topic:eek:. She's so rude:down:!
     
  6. atry

    atry Member

    Yes, but David Attenborough handled the entire thing with grace and class. I can imagine others who wouldn't.
     
  7. DILLIGAF

    DILLIGAF New Member

    Oh yeah? What do you know about working in TV?
     
  8. tirial

    tirial IT fixer extraordinaire

    Over a decade working in it.
     
  9. skye

    skye Member

    Come on, we should give her some leeway. She's obviously a junior presenter.
     
  10. Reader

    Reader Vile Critic

    I am not a great lover of her work, as I find the number of stutters, disfluencies, and fillers in her questions to be distracting during her interviews.

    While anyone can be allowed one slip, this is hardly her worst interview. The one she did with Sadiq Khan was uncomfortable to watch. Normally I appreciate watching an interviewer nailing a politician to the wall, but she seemed to be trying to do it using rubber nails and a Fisher Price hammer.
     
  11. DILLIGAF

    DILLIGAF New Member

    Well shut my mouth. Sorry.
     
  12. Tregaron

    Tregaron Member

    She's paid between £150,000 and £199,999 and worked for the BBC and Channel 4.
     
  13. Angel

    Angel Munificent Critic

    Now while I understand the public fascination with the ship named after him, but I thought the point of an interview was to be stick to a single subject and inform as much as possible on it.

    She seemed to have her own questions she was looking to have answered which differed from the ones everyone else was expecting. It's not like there was a scoop waiting to happen, which makes me wonder why on earth she did it?
     
  14. skye

    skye Member

    I take it back. How on earth did she get that job?
     
  15. Post-Life Crisis

    Post-Life Crisis New Member


Site Sponsors