Well, we are still receiving novels for review that are not on the site, despite conversations like this and the notice on the Review Policy page. I do like @C. Lee McKenzie's suggestions, of giving the author a chance to read the review first, as we are going to be blunt and honest about it. The review policy on paperbackraider makes a lot of sense. Is it worth trying to follow that? Yes, I am aware this is me changing my mind.