Quantcast
Follow on RSS Follow on Twitter Follow on Linked In

Bargain on 10th - 14th Jul 19
View on Amazon.co.uk
 

Read Review

Top - Reviews - Newspaper - Update Details

This book was featured in the newspaper column - click for details

Emily Neuburger, Parents.com

“Shirley Link is a new girl detective series that my daughter is crazy about. This is an amazing series, my friends! Your kids will be hooked and you’ll feel really good about it.”

Shirley Link is a 12-year old private eye, but she doesn’t want anyone to know. Whenever she uses her powers of observation she gets into trouble.

An example?

She wrote a school paper about a tough case she’d solved over summer vacation.

“It’s not a creative writing assignment, Shirley,” the teacher scolded. “You were supposed to write about what actually happened.”

“I did,” she said, louder than she meant to. But he gave her a D anyway.

So when the school principal needs Shirley’s help to catch a thief she tries to do it quietly. Can she track down a criminal who’s clever enough to steal $35,000 and the one-ton safe it was kept in? Can she do it without the whole world finding out about her detective skills?

Hint: the answer to one of those questions is, no.

A great read for kids (and their adults).

Bargain on 10th - 14th Jul 19
View on Amazon.co.uk

Reviews:

"Written in first person, this is an enjoyable children's book...which can be enjoyed by young children for the characters, older ones for the mystery, and adults looking for light escapism. "

Reviewer: .


Shirley Link is a great detective, and she's only twelve. She's been keeping the fact secret from her school life, until the Principal approaches her in the library: $30,000 dollars has gone missing from a safe in his office and he's facing the sack. What can Shirley do but agree to find the money, especially as his likely successor is Shirley's least favorite teacher of all. So helped and hindered by her friends, Marie and Wylie, she sets out to solve the case.

Written in first person, this is an enjoyable children's book. Shirley is insightful, intelligent, and quite likely to rub people the wrong way: a veritable twelve-year-old Sherlock Holmes. With her mother a police officer and her father an archaeologist who takes her tomb raiding in the holidays, it was probably inevitable she'd develop odd interests. The characters aren't described in detail but given that they are seen only through Shirley's eyes, and she is twelve, that is understandable. There is enough there to get a picture of the cast and what's going on behind the scenes, and it ends with the classic "all suspects in one place" resolution.

In terms of story, the plot hangs together well, and the resolution is believable. I didn't solve it, because I over-thought it, but I still enjoyed the journey even though I'm hardly the target market. A picky older reader might wonder what the principal was doing with $30,000 in a safe not a bank, why such a good detective can't get a pass to make class up if she's on a case, and why her mother isn't tearing the teacher a new one for marking Shirley down for telling the truth...but since it all sets up a great locked room mystery, these little annoyances can be quickly forgiven.

The formatting is good, the cover striking and appropriate for the genre, and I didn't spot any typos. The main short story makes up 65% of the ebook, and is followed by a short mystery for the reader to solve "The Cowgirl's Keys", which is a good short with a pagebreak before the solution. Then there are fifty riddles, which are original as far as I can tell, but while they are fun it does seem a little like padding for page count. Then at the end there's a link to get the next ebook in the series for free.

I'd probably place Shirley Link's target audience at ages 7-12, though the reference to an affair might pitch it at the higher end of that.Some of the references will date the book, e.g. a reference to a console that has already been replaced, but the inclusion of modern technology is part of the solution was good, and so true to life that I laughed.

In conclusion it is a good short story, which can be enjoyed by young children for the characters, older ones for the mystery, and adults looking for light escapism.

Rating: 4



Top - Reviews - Newspaper - Update Details

Third Party Reviews:


No reviews yet. Why not link one?

You can suggest a blog review here

Newspaper Review:

This book was featured in our newspaper column - click for larger version
This book was one of our Reviewer's Choices to be featured in our newspaper column. Click here for more information.

Top - Reviews - Newspaper - Update Details

Discussion

New to the site? Leave a comment below or view the chat on our forum here:

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Your Website (optional)

Your Message



*Your email will not be displayed on the site. All message are held for moderation.



Top - Reviews - Newspaper - Update Details




Bookangel.co.uk