Christmas with Uncle Nick and the Sugar Plum Fairies


... Get an illustrator and credit your images, and it would go up. ...

Bobby and Cindy’s parents are going to a christmas ball and they’ve arranged a very special babysitter. Uncle Nick takes them through the power cut with a story of Santa, dragons and fairies…

Upfront I must state I have great concerns about this book as it includes a number of images, which have obviously been culled from several artists (including christ card covers and a shot of the grinch), but contains no credits or copyright notice. Some images contain their own, but not many e.g. L.Burns © 1984. Even if these are out of copyright or creative commons, I’d have expected some attribution, and no illustrator is credited. As such I cannot recommend this book until that is resolved.

The author’s website is a blog with one post on housecleaning, and the email given bounced so we were not able to check this.

It is a sweet story and if I was rating on the story alone I would give it a 3. However, it really needed its own illustrator. The mix of styles and low quality web images with artifacting, sometimes tilted at odd angles, are simply distracting. There are typing mistakes (“Uncle Nicked” and “Santa Clause” are sadly spelling errors not jokes) and some of the images are over expanded and low quality.

It includes a recipe for sugar plums and the poem “The Night before Christmas” which is woven through the story.

1 star. Get an illustrator and credit your images, and it would go up. Right now I cannot advise spending money on this

Rating: 1
Reviewed by
Reviewed on:
Review Policy: No compensation is received for reviews. View our Review Policy here.


Other reviews you might like:


  • Max, the boy who didn't believe in Santa Claus
    Five stars for this lovely Christmas tale with a laugh-out-loud - and heartwarming - ending. Good for those that believe in Santa and those that don't - and the parents will like it too!
  • The Christmas Gift
    An unseasonal story perhaps and yet still absolutely hilarious.
  • The Christmas Tin II
    three absolutely wonderful short Christmas stories of hope and triumph, embedded in a double-framing structure, which is over-extended and rather dry.

321

Discussion

rz3300 (23 August 2016)
Well, if nothing else, the title is certainly intriguing. I am not really sure what it is, but I have always liked the longer titles and the ones that really leave things open to interpretation. It seems like these can really do in a lot of different directions, which makes them exciting to start and then see where they end up going. The whole sugar plum fairies aspect is very intriguing, too, so I will definitely look into this one. Thanks for sharing.

New to the site? Leave a comment below or view the chat on our forum here:

You are commenting as a Guest: Login Or Register

Your Message



*Your email will not be displayed on the site. All message are held for moderation.