Margot gets an unexpected visit


...There is nothing wrong with the story itself, which is great for kids, but the presentation needs a little work to improve readability....

Margot the Groundhog gets an unexpected visitor: Marie the little girl from Belgium she met last year. This year Marie has even brought her sister, Lowieske, to visit during the Ice Hockey world cup, where they will all support Canada.

The cover isn’t promising, with two children photoshopped over a photo of a groundhog, but it does the job. The book has an unusual layout, which causes some problems. Each page has a full-colour wildlife photograph, carefully faded in places to allow the words to show up clearly. It is a beautiful and artistic effect, and an unusual one for a children’s book. Unfortunately it is somewhat let down by the photoshop used to insert the girl’s pictures, which are low-res and have occasionally jagged and blurred edges. Some of the images, like the groundhog with glasses or scuba mask will appeal to children.

The writing is simple, ideal for young children and early readers, but the text is part of the image and not resizeable so it may be easier if someone reads it to them. In places the dark grey text is still harder to read against the text, and I am curious about whether this book would display on an e-ink reader.

There is nothing wrong with the story itself, which is great for kids, but the presentation needs a little work to improve readability.

Rating: 3
Reviewed by
Reviewed on:
Review Policy: No compensation is received for reviews. View our Review Policy here.


Other reviews you might like:


  • FindBella: FindBella – the search to bring Bella home
    while it is a sensitive memoir of an upsetting event, the typos and contradictions do mean I would be hesitant about recommending it. For anyone involved with the Save Bella facebook page and campaign, this would be a nice memoir and reminder.
  • Escape from Cold Ditch
    Sly humour, in-jokes, sometimes dark comedy, and a not entirely happy ending that makes this the type of children's book that will endure and a blend of sadness and humour that children will love.
  • The Winter Freak Show
    ...a gem of a story. This is perfect for children, and enjoyable at any age.

Discussion

rz3300 (22 August 2016)
Well again I will choose to take it as more of a challenge. I have to say that the title really lends itself to mystery, which is always good in my opinion. I am always open to stories that are good for children, too, just given the nature of my work. Presentation is one thing that I can work with, though, so I might have a good time with this one. Thanks for sharing.

New to the site? Leave a comment below or view the chat on our forum here:

You are commenting as a Guest: Login Or Register

Your Message



*Your email will not be displayed on the site. All message are held for moderation.