Mr Mars – Our Boy: Marley’s Story

Listing on BookAngel:

Mr Mars - Our Boy: Marley’s Story

Last Free Dates: 19th Mar 21 to 21st Mar 21
Read More

View on

...Due to the formatting and writing issues I cannot recommend it, but for those who knew Marley, it would make a good memorial....

I picked this up because I have a soft spot for animal stories and pet biographies.

In the first few pages there are some funny stories. I am sure any dog owner can appreciate the problems with a black Labrador that returns from the beach brown with mud, and the following job of cleaning out the newly-recoloured car. It is a short book, a homage to Marley “Mr Mars” the Labrador’s nine years with his family. It begins when he was born and ends, as it must, in the inevitable heartbreak for any pet owner. His friends, his life and times, and a section of photos all make this a notable tribute to a notable dog.

However, there are significant issues with it as a book. The formatting is unusual, with sections separated by left-aligned titles, indented, underlined and in normal text. Lines separate sections and some paragraphs, though the paragraph beginnings are also indented.

The writing style is technically in first person, but reads like a blog rather than a book. For example, when his family are named, ages in brackets follow each name. Stray capitals can be found e.g. “I Stood…” and “with Me and Jo all…”. Commas appear irregularly, sometimes correctly, sometimes missing, and sometimes substituting for other punctuation e.g. “his food, When…” should be a full stop. The Oxford comma is absent, resulting in some odd lists. A classic example is the extract “our cat Tigers food bowl” which is missing both commas and apostrophes. All the errors I mention here are on the first page, so I will not continue; however, readers should be aware that this style continues throughout.

It is obvious the author has put their heart and soul into the stories and I will say that for those who knew Marley, it would make a good memorial.

I am not rating this as due to the formatting and writing issues, I cannot recommend it. A proof-reader, editor, or the simple and old trick of reading backwards, would allow many of the formatting errors to be fixed.

Rating: Unrated
Reviewed by
Reviewed on:
Review Policy: No compensation is received for reviews. View our Review Policy here.

Other reviews you might like:

  • The Petectives
    This is a fun little story. The plot, characters, and dialog are all sharply written and enough to hold this reader to the end, when I put the book down with a smile.
  • Boy and the Very Lonely Pony
    For the 4-6 age ranges, this is a lovely little book...with full colour illustrations reminiscent of The Snowman.
  • Night Market
    You don't need to known anything about the culture, or Taiwan to know and love good storytelling, and these stories are excellent.


sliara (11 June 2021)
So this one has a lot of formatting errors. Who would have thought, right? Maybe a beginner wrote that book. Oh well, I guess better luck next time.

Reader (14 June 2021)
*So this one has a lot of formatting errors. Who would have thought, right? Maybe a beginner wrote that book. Oh well, I guess better luck next time.* The problem is that, beginner or not, they are still asking people to spend money to buy it as a product. A basic level of competence is expected for a commercial product, and this did not meet it. As a free book to give out to family and friends, that is acceptable. If you want strangers to pay for it, then you owe your audience more care.

New to the site? Leave a comment below or view the chat on our forum here:

You are commenting as a Guest: Login Or Register

Your Message

*Your email will not be displayed on the site. All message are held for moderation.